Use of Planktonic/Benthic Foraminiferal Ratios to Quantify ...

Use of Planktonic/Benthic Foraminiferal Ratios to Quantify ...

Use of Planktonic/Benthic Foraminiferal Ratios to Quantify Water Depth and Dissolution during the PETM from the Cambrian-Dorchester Core Nicole Flynn Senior Thesis: The Pennsylvania State University Advisor: Timothy Bralower Introduction: Paleocene Eocene Thermal Maximum (PETM) Oceanic temperature increase Massive input

of isotopically depleted carbon Bottom waters: 4-5C Methane clathrates in marine sediments on continental coasts (Kennett and Stott, 1991; Bralower et al., 1995) Tropical surface waters: 5C High latitude surface waters: 9C

(Dickens et al., 1995) 3-4 permil negative shift in carbon isotope values (see compilation of Dunkley Jones et al., 2013) (Pagani et al., 2006; McInerney and Wing, 2011) http://www.dep.state.fl.us/ geology/geologictopics/ rocks/time_scale.htm

Introduction: Paleocene Eocene Thermal Maximum Changes in carbon cycling, marine and terrestrial environments/ecosystems Shoaling (e. g., Colosimo et al., 2006, Petrizzo et l., 2007) Ocean acidification (Doney, SC et at., 2009) Decreased pH Dissolution and reduced calcification of foraminifera

Lysocline Depth where rate of calcite dissolution dramatically increases Calcite Compensation Depth (CCD) Depth where rate of calcite accumulation equals rate of calcite dissolution

Introduction: Sea Level Sea level rise documented during PETM (Zachos et al., 2005) (e.g., Sluijs et al., 2006, Sluijs et al., 2011) Warming temperatures during PETM Limited ice sheets Minor rise due to melting of ice sheets Thermal expansion Increase in energy

Increase in bond length Increase in volume Introduction: Foraminifera Single-celled animals Form test of CaCO3 Carbon isotope excursion from composition Approximately 270,000 species Benthic Planktonic http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foraminifera (Haynes, 1981)

http://paleopolis.rediris.es/cg/CG2010_BOOK_02/index.html Introduction: Foraminifera Extinction Benthic Foraminifera Largest extinction in last 90 million years 50% species extinction Planktonic Foraminifera Diversification (Kelly et al., 1996) (e.g. Scheibner, 2005; Alegret, 2009).

http://pubs.usgs.gov/of/2000/of00-304/htmldocs/chap09/ http://www.ok4me2.net/page/11/?s=microscope Introduction: Cambrian-Dorchester (CamDor) August 2009 Dorchester County, Maryland Coordinates: 38N, 70W ~753-749 ft. ~749-732 ft. Heavily bioturbated, glauconitic sand Paleocene- Aquia Formation glauconitic quartz sand

Eocene- Marlboro Clay Formation kaolinite rich clays ~732-725 ft. ~725-719 ft. Clay, very fine sand, quartz with minor glauconite ~719-712 ft. ~712-695 ft. Clay, faint bedding and bioturbation, sparse benthics ~695-679 ft.

~679-669 ft. Sandy clay, heavily bioturbated, echinoid spines, oyster shell bed Introduction: Cam-Dor Cont. PlanktonicBenthic ratios Fragmentation Quartz, pyrite, Dissolution and glauconite Sea level

turbulence Environmental changes http:// health.wikinut.c om/img/ 2d94qwjwf6qfq 4xq/ClearQuartz-Point http://www.fabreminerals.com/ LargePhoto.php? FILE=specimens/s_imagesQ1/ PyriteGB86Q1f.jpg&CODE=GB86Q1& NAME=Octahedral

http://www.chinaneolithic.com/en/Mineral/Photos.asp?id=318 Introduction: Hypotheses 1. There will be an increase in P/B ratio following the PaleoceneEocene boundary after the onset of the PETM 2. a. Deep ocean acidification will lead to increased fragmentation in both benthic and planktonic foraminifera, with particularly more fragmentation in planktonics at the base b. Turbulent shelf environment will lead to increased fragmentation in both planktonic and benthic foraminifera at the top 3. Quartz and glauconite percentages will increase with decreasing core depth and pyrite percentages will decrease with decreasing depth due to falling sea levels

Methods: Retrieval 1. 156 samples from Cam-Dor core 2. Distance between samples varied based on proximity to contact 3. Closer together if closer to contact 4. Stored in sealed plastic bags Methods: Washing Process 1. 75 washed purification 2. Sieved into 3 fractions:

63-125 m 125-250 m >250 m 3. 125-250 m fraction analyzed Methods: Analysis and Identification 100 counts Planktonic Fragmented planktonic Benthic Fragmented benthic

Percentages of Pyrite Glauconite Quartz Very little in five samples from: 732.55-730.85 ft. Small decrease in two samples: 725.69 ft. 725.2 ft. Missing from: 732.55 to 730.85 ft. Increase from:

730.35 to 722.5 ft. Average: 1.6 Decrease from: 719.5 to 669.28 ft. Average: 0.7 Benthic: blue 730.35 to 680.28 ft: 19.4% 677.2 to 669.82 ft: 62% Planktonics: red Average: 30.3% Comparison Slightly more fragmented

planktonics than benthics at base Quartz: blue Decrease Pyrite: red Decrease Glauconite: green Increase Discussion: P/B Ratio Dissolution zone missing planktonic and benthic foraminifera deep ocean acidification/rising CCD Rise in P/B ratio

Increase in SL from 730.35722.5 Highest P/B ratio: 3.8 79% of foraminifera planktonic Highest SL at 726.6 feet Decrease in P/B ratio Drop in SL as ocean water temperature decrease after PETM from 719.5 to 669.82 Increase in benthic activity Discussion: Fragmentation

Benthic Foraminifera Planktonic Foraminifera Bottom- Fragmentation due to dissolution Top- Turbulence associated with decreasing sea levels Increased fragmentation in planktonics at bottom due to dissolution Planktonics more susceptible than benthics

Overall average: 30.3% Discussion: Quartz, pyrite, glauconite Quartz Disagrees with hypothesis Due to relative glauconite percentages http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quartz Pyrite Agrees with hypothesis Decreasing pyrite

Decreasing SL corresponds with decrease in pyrite Pyrite indicates eutrophication during PETM Glauconite Agrees with hypothesis Return to continental shelf marine depositional environment

http://euromin.w3sites.net/mineraux/PYRITE.html http://www.chinaneolithic.net/en/Mineral/photos.asp?ID=318 Conclusions Dissolution Sea Level Rise Massive carbon Rise in SL following the input lead to Paleoceneocean Eocene contact acidification or

shoaling CCD Rise in P/B ratio from 730.35 to Dissolution 725.69 feet zone from Increased 732.55 to pyrite730.85 feet eutrophication Sea Level Fall Fall in SL due to falling temperatures

recovery Fall in P/B ratio from 725.2 to 669.82 feet Increased glauconite ? ? ? ? ? Questions?

Recently Viewed Presentations

  • Map of Athens and Sparta, 5th century BCE

    Map of Athens and Sparta, 5th century BCE

    Each group will use the information given to identify if a city state would join either the Peloponnesian or Delian League based on Government, quality of life, treatment of non citizens and trade. Use the skeletal outline and review information...
  • CS 3501 - Chapter 3 (3A and 10.2.2)

    CS 3501 - Chapter 3 (3A and 10.2.2)

    * Consensus Theorem F(x,y,z) = xy + x′z + yz Consensus Theorem Dr. Clincy * Working backwards and adding a term * Through our exercises in simplifying Boolean expressions, we see that there are numerous ways of stating the same...
  • LAST WORDS LAST WORDS Concern (24) Let no

    LAST WORDS LAST WORDS Concern (24) Let no

    Philippians 2:4 ESV (4) Let each of you look not only to his own interests, but also to the interests of others. 1 Corinthians 12:24b-26 ESV (24) … But God has so composed the body, giving greater honor to the...
  • Strategies to Improve Breastfeeding Outcomes in Your Hospital

    Strategies to Improve Breastfeeding Outcomes in Your Hospital

    THIS WAS THE GAME CHANGER/THIS GAVE " BREASTFEEDING AS BEST PRACTICE" a green light. ... The American Cancer Society now includes breastfeeding when discussing behaviors that can reduce a woman's risk of breast cancer. ... Baby Friendly Designation Model Hospital...
  • Nat Turner - Kidblog Inc.

    Nat Turner - Kidblog Inc.

    Nat Turner was never a rebellious slave, well not until he noticed what was going on, all the signs around him have a reason, but what? starting a rebellion means taking risk for everyone, even his family. Why would he...
  • 5-HT transporter promoter polymorphism (5-HTTLPR,17q11) (SLC6A4) Adapted from

    5-HT transporter promoter polymorphism (5-HTTLPR,17q11) (SLC6A4) Adapted from

    BDNF: Val66met Cells: Intracellular trafficking and regulated secretion Systems: hippo- campal processing bipolar disorder, schizophrenia Alzheimer's Disease, antidepressant effects Behavior: complex functional interactions and emergent phenomena CBDB/NIMH: Investigators Clinical genetics Michael Egan Terry Goldberg Thomas Hyde Lewellyn ...
  • Nouns

    Nouns

    Abstract nouns: name ideas, qualities, or feelings that cannot be seen or touched. Truth, courage, time, history, heritage. Time for practice. Get a Writer's Choice Book from my cabinet (green books) Turn to page 382. Complete Ex. 1 #'s 1-10.
  • Chapter 7 Section 3 Notes The Midwestern States

    Chapter 7 Section 3 Notes The Midwestern States

    Chapter 7 Section 3 Notes The Midwestern States ... The Chicago Mercantile Exchange is the world's busiest market for many farm products. The Chicago Board of Trade is the largest grain exchange. Industry, Resources, and Transportation The Midwest is home...