Sampling - University of Idaho

Sampling - University of Idaho

Soil Solution Sampling Ralph Oborn Precisionist 1 Precision Agriculture Grower challenges New technologies Spatial and temporal variabilities Increase labor costs Lower profits

Yield and Quality bonus Environmental concerns 2 Precision Agriculture Goal: Just the right amount at Just the right place at Just the right time 3 Information As growers have better information Can make better decisions Agronomically Economically

Environmentally 4 Soils Healthy soil is about 50% solids, 25% water, 25% air 0% Bone Dry Wilt Point Plant cannot remove any more water. Pores are slightly filled with water film

(Only in laboratory at held by surface tension 100 C) Soil has no moisture. Pores are empty. 50% 100% Available water Most crops do best when soil

moisture is between 50% and 100% of available water. Field Capacity Saturation All soil pores Soil can hold no are totally filled. Water more water. puddles on Any additional water flows with surface and

flows to next gravity. lower level 5 Soil: Vadose Zone Between surface and water table Air, Water, Solids, OM etc

Non homogeneous!! 3D spatial variability Chemicals Pores Big and small 6 Pores Macropores Larger Freeways for flow Fast

Relatively little interchange with solids Pores Smaller City streets for flow Slow Tortuosity Large amount of

interaction 7 Soil Solution Quantity Movement (flux) Constituents Dissolved Ions Colloids Amount taken up by roots is very complex That which is not used becomes problematic

Potential to leach into ground and surface water 8 Soil Solution Saturated flow Macro pore Capillary flow Unsaturated flow Capillary flow Tightly held Interstitial 9

Idealized Soil Water Flow Life would be easy 10 Reality Soil Water Flow Obstructions Variable Flux Rate Convergence Divergence Variable Concentration

Variable Quantity 11 Need for Measurements Agronomic Make sure crop is adequately supplied Economic Avoid waste Environmental Avoid loose contaminants If its going to be used, its a nutrient If not it's a contaminant

12 Areas of Concern Coarse sandy soils Nitrates Available to crops (my interest) Available to leach (environmental concern) 13 Needed: Holy Grail of Samplers

Quantity Flux (movement) Constituents Star Trek Tricorder 14 Needed: Samplers Integrated area Large to be representative Low cost Ease of maintenance

Repeatable Nondestructive Continuous Multiple levels Accurate 15 Current Art

Moisture quantity Tradition Look and feel Gravimetric Tensionometer Neutron probe ET match TDR Capacitance

Solution sampling Core extraction Pan lysimeters Porous cup Wick 16 Moisture Quantity

Tradition Look and feel Gravimetric Tensionometer Neutron Probe ET Match TDR Capacitance Continuous, current, multiple depth, large volume 17 Capacitance Probe

Free Drainage Irrigation Scheduling Daily Crop Usage Depth of root zone Calibrate to quantity, Get an idea of flux, no solution data Penetration

Control Leaching Sentek EnviroScan 18 Solution Sampling Core extraction Pan lysimeters Porous cup Wick

Placement of all samplers is extremely critical What part of soil solution are you measuring? Free water Large pore Small pore Interstitial in clay 19 Reality Soil Water Flow 20

Soil Core Solution Extraction Remove Soil Core Extract soil solution Analyze Fixed volume (good)

Destructive Non repeatable Difficult to extract What portion are you extracting? Quantity - maybe Flux no Solution - maybe 21 Pan Lysimeters Needs good soil contact Drips - only gets saturated flow (macro pore) Divergence of

unsaturated flow around sampler Saturated flow can be more dilute Create capillary fringe Unsure of sampling volume 22 Porous Cup Ceramic interface Similar to soil Hydraulically Vacuum applied to extract solution Continuous

Intermittent Saturated and unsaturated flow 1904 Artificial Root Gradient of suction 23 Porous Cup Diversions Can divert streamflows Uncertain sampling volume Ineffective for clay

24 Porous Cup Diversions Intermittent sampling may not match intermittent flow May miss flux front May miss solution front 25 Porous Cup Diversions Too much suction removes nearby,

tightly held, high concentration water Wilt point 26 In a Nutshell One cannot be sure from what macroscopic volume of soil the sample was extracted nor from which pores it was drained England 27 Porous Cup Conclusions

Quantity - no Flux no Solution - maybe 28 Wick Sampler Hanging water column Wick designed to match soil suction Continuous sampling No distortion of streamlines

Only samples available water Relatively easy to install, maintain, use, sample No continuous power Brown 1986 29 Wick 30 Wicks

Wicks must be prepared Heat to 400C Splay and secure on collector plate Must be held tightly to soil Measure collected volume Capture solution for analysis Doesnt sorb or slow down collection Large integrated sampling area 31 Wick Sizing

Number of Wicks = Ksat soil x Plate Area Ksat wick x Wick Area K Sat Soil ~ 2.54 cm/hr Ksat Wick ~ 36 cm/hr Wick area ~ 1.2 cm2 32 Wick Research

Flux rates Sorption properties Installation methods Sampling methods 33 Wick Conclusion Quantity Yes Flux Yes

Constitutes _ Yes Becoming just a tool 34 Conclusion A large cross section together with a low extraction rate can yield a sample large enough for chemical analysis 35 For More Information

Knutson, J. H. and J. S. Selker. 1996. Fiberglass wick sampler effects on measurements of solute transport in the vadose zone. Soil Science Society of America Journal 60: 420-424. Zhu, Y, R. H. Fox, and J. D. Toth. 2002. Leachate Collection Efficiency of Zero-tension Pan and Passive Capillary Fiberglass Wick Lysimeters. Soil Science Society of America Journal 66:37-43.

Rimmer, Alon, Tammo S. Steenhuis, and John S. Selker . 1995. One Dimensional Model to Evaluate the Performance of Wick Samplers in Soils. Soil Science Society of America Journal 59:88-92. Goyne, Keith W., Rick L. Day, and Jon Chorover. 2000. Artifacts caused by collection of soil Solution with Passive Capillary Samplers. Soil Science Society of America Journal 64:1330-1336. Brandi-Dohrn, Florian, Richard P. Dick, Mario Hess, John S. Selker. 1996. Suction Cup Sampler Bias in Leaching Characterization of and Undisturbed Field Soil. Water Resources Research. Research. 32:1173-1182. Barbee, G. C., and K. W. Brown. 1986. Comparison Between Suction and Free Drainage Soil Solution Samplers. Soil Science. 141:149-154. Wood, Warren W. 1973. A Technique Using Porous Cups for Water Sampling at Any Depth in the Unsaturated Zone. Water Resources Research. Research. 9(2):486-488. England, C. B., Comments on A Technique Using Porous Cups for Water Sampling at Any Depth in the Unsaturated Zone by Warren Wood. 1974. Water Resources Research. 10(5):1049. Boll, J., J. S. Selker, B. M. Nijssen, T. S. Steenhuis, J. Van Winkle. and E. Jolles. Water Quality Sampling Under Preferential Flow Conditions. In p290-298. R. G. Allen et al. (ed.) Lysimeters for Evapotranspiration and Environmental Measurements. Procedings ASCE International Symposium. Lysimetry, Honolulu,

Hawaii. 23-25 July 1991. ASCE, New York. Poletika, N. N., Roth, K., and W. A. Jury. 1992. Interpretation of solute transport data obtained with fiberglass wick soil solution samplers. Soil Science Society of America Journal 56: 1751-1753. Boll, J., T. S. Steenhuis, and J. S. Selker, 1992. Fiberglass Wicks for Sampling of Water and Solutes in the Vadose Zone. Soil Science Society of America Journal 56:701-707. Knutson, John H., and John S. Selker. 1994. Unsaturated Hydraulic Conductivities of Fiberglass Wicks and Designing Capillary Wick Pore-Water Samplers. 1994. Soil Science Society of America Journal. Journal. 58:721-729. 58:721-729. 36

Recently Viewed Presentations

  • 7 -

    7 -

    Structure of a Typical Rib. Main parts: Head. Articulates posteriorly with facets (demifacets) on bodies of two adjacent vertebrae. Neck. Tubercle. Articulates posteriorly with transverse costal facet of same-numbered thoracic vertebra. Shaft. Figure 7.23a.
  • Oracle Concepts Part 6: Create Tables and Data Structures

    Oracle Concepts Part 6: Create Tables and Data Structures

    Oracle Concepts Part 6: Create Tables and Data Structures Dr. Sam E. Sambasivam Azusa Pacific University Control User Access The database administrator provides users with access to tables using the SQL security commands Control User Access Provide accesses to the...
  • PowerPoint Presentation

    PowerPoint Presentation

    Demonstrations Discussion groups Exceptions: answers to quick quizzes and quizzes What you will need, as soon as possible: The textbook: Physics for Scientists and Engineers, Knight Your McMaster WebCT account - go to T13 if you need help setting it...


    Assumption: Successful programs must address cultural values of youth, school and peer relationships, and extended family and work. Change does not occur in isolation . Therapeutic setting with goals and accountability. Extends the duration and intensity of the treatment model.
  • What Is the Difference Between a Rhyming and an Alliterating ...

    What Is the Difference Between a Rhyming and an Alliterating ...

    Ankylosaurus was built like a tank, Its hide was a fortress as sturdy as steel, It tended to be an inedible meal. It was armored in front, it was armored behind, There wasn't a thing on its minuscule mind, It...
  • Persian Wars ause of wars: Athenian support of

    Persian Wars ause of wars: Athenian support of

    A magnificent orator with a reputation for scrupulous honesty, Pericles deepened and extended the reforms that Cleisthenes had set in motion some 50 years before. A keen patron of learning and the arts, he masterminded the construction of the Parthenon.
  • Cell biology - S.M.Joshi College

    Cell biology - S.M.Joshi College

    Understand that cholesterol in mammalian membranes reduces membrane fluidity and permeability to some solutes. Membrane structure Analyse evidence from electron microscopy that led to the proposal of the Davson-Danielli model. Analyse the falsification of the Davson-Danielli model that led to...
  • Take-Back Legislation Sustainable Operations Prof. Gil Souza Environmental

    Take-Back Legislation Sustainable Operations Prof. Gil Souza Environmental

    Scope of This Presentation. We will focus on environmental legislation regarding product take-back. Manufacturers are responsible for environmentally responsible treatment of products that reach the end of their useful lives