Pojman against Relativism - Texas A&M University

Pojman against Relativism - Texas A&M University

Ethical Relativism Relevant Terms Subjective Relativism (Subjectivism) The view that right actions are those sanctioned by a person Cultural Relativism (Conventionalism) The view that right actions are those sanctioned by ones culture

Moral Objectivism The view that there are moral norms or principles that are valid or true for everyone The argument for Relativism P1. Beliefs about what is right and wrong differ across cultures (the Diversity thesis). P2. What is right and wrong is dependent upon, or relative to, culture (the Dependency thesis). -- C. Thus, there is no objective right and wrong.

The argument appears valid, and thus to defeat the conclusion Pojman will need to defeat at least one of the premises. P1 is simply a statement of fact, and thus hard to overcome. Thus the weaker premise is P2. The strength of P2 resides in the nature of the dependency implied by the

premise, i.e. what degree of dependency does the relativist require to uphold the conclusion, and can sufficient fault be found to undermine the argument? Strong vs. Weak Dependency Weak Dependency - expressions of a moral belief X can differ across culture Strong Dependency - the moral belief X itself can differ across culture

To make the argument stick, the relativist is going to have to claim strong dependence. The attack on P2 If relativism is correct, it leads to two possible interpretations: Subjectivism: morality is dependent on individuals, not culture Conventionalism: morality is dependent on culture

For Pojmans attack to be successful, he will have to show that both subjectivism and conventionalism are false. Subjectivism leads to absurd conclusions Conventionalism collapses into Subjectivism

'morality' has no meaning no interpersonal criticism is possible How do we determine what a society is? How is reform possible within a conventionalist system? No intercultural moral critique is possible. In addition, relativism (in both forms) entails relativ tolerance. If so, then relativism entails at least

one objective moral value (tolerance). If so, then relativism is not true for all moral values. Alternatives to Relativism Moral Objectivism- there are some (at least one) universalizable moral principles. Moral Absolutism - there are some (at least one) universalizable moral principles which are inviolable.

The nature of universalizable principles Alleviation of suffering Avoid/resolve social conflicts Promote human flourishing/survival Pojmans argument for Objectivism P1. Objective moral principles are those adherence to which meet the needs and

promote the most significant needs of persons. P2. Some principles are such that adherence to them meets and promotes the significant needs of persons. -- C1. Thus, there are some objective moral rules.

Recently Viewed Presentations

  • Amateur Radio Technician Class Element 2 Course Presentation

    Amateur Radio Technician Class Element 2 Course Presentation

    The deviation of an FM transmitter is set too low . T7B04Which of the following is a way to reduce or eliminate interference by an amateur transmitter to a nearby telephone? Put a filter on the amateur transmitter. Reduce the...
  • Meet the teacher 2014 - Oatley Public School

    Meet the teacher 2014 - Oatley Public School

    Bug Club and Mathletics (optional) TALKING AND LISTENING. News. Keeping Informed. School Stream app. Oatley Public School website www.oatleypublicschool.nsw.edu.au. Stage One Newsletter - Twice a term. OPS Strategic DirectionsSchool Plan 2018-2020.
  • The One Minute Preceptor - University of Nevada, Reno School ...

    The One Minute Preceptor - University of Nevada, Reno School ...

    The One Minute Preceptor Video. Please click the link below to watcha 2-minute video of the One Minute Preceptor in action: This brief video features Dr. Ivan Lopez, Director, Renown Institute for . Neurosciences; Professor . and . Chair, Department...
  • Test Driven Development.ppt - University of Calgary

    Test Driven Development.ppt - University of Calgary

    FIT for Embedded System Test Development PRESENTER : Jingwen Chen Main topics Agile methodology from the desktop world XP Inspired embedded system life-cycle Adapting FIT into embedded system development What is FIT/FitNesse EmbeddedFitNesse testing framework MatLab/C++ FitNesse testing framework Issues...
  • Chapter 7: Energy

    Chapter 7: Energy

    Note that work is a way of transferring energy from one form to another, but itself is not a form of energy. Energy cannot be created or destroyed; it may be transformed from one form into another, but the total...
  • Supporting Learning in the Workplace With thanks to

    Supporting Learning in the Workplace With thanks to

    making physical changes - eg installing a ramp for a wheelchair user or an audio-visual fire alarm for a deaf person. letting a disabled person work somewhere else - eg on the ground floor for a wheelchair user. changing their...
  • Divine Command Theory Weaknesses

    Divine Command Theory Weaknesses

    Divine Command Theory Weaknesses - Lesson 2. Summarise DCT weaknesses in word cloud format, using notes from last lesson. (the bigger the word, the more significant it is) To further explore the philosophical weaknesses of divine command theory. To discuss...
  • Umayyad and Abbasid - White Plains Middle School

    Umayyad and Abbasid - White Plains Middle School

    Science and Math! Abbasid scholars preserved Greek works of medicine, algebra, geometry, astronomy, anatomy, and ethics. Arabic traders in India carried the Indian number system across Mediter. and into Northern Europe. These number systems became ESSENTIAL to Scientific Revolution in...