California water fix South delta water agency parties

California water fix South delta water agency parties

SDWA-322 CALIFORNIA WATER FIX Part 2 Rebuttal REBUTTAL TESTIMONY OF DR. JEFFREY MICHAEL REBUTTAL OUTLINE 1) Gwen Buchholz (DWR 1010) a) b) c) 2) SDWA-322 EIR/EIS does not support claims about economic

public interest. Project Description Is Inconsistent with WaterFix Economic/Financial Analysis and Evolving Financial Plan Benefits to Agriculture Inaccurate As Financial Plan Changes Dr. Michael Shires (WWD 18) a. b. Exaggerates Contribution of WWD. Mostly Irrelevant to Petition. (although one can indirectly infer WaterFix harms WWD) SDWA-322 Economic Public Interest Comments Are Not Supported Buchholz: Overall, implementation of CWF

H3+ will improve water supply, ecosystem conditions, and economics of the state of California. Expert panels for water supply and environmental interests. Economics No Expert Panel. No Feasibility or Benefit-Cost Assessment. Only cited EIR-EIS for support. The EIR/EIS Does Not Support Any Conclusions About Economic Public Interest SDWA-322 From EIR/S Socioeconomic Chapter (emphasis added) DWRs Economic Analysis Guidebook provides guidance regarding the

economic assessments that should be conducted from project formulation through implementation. These include cost effectiveness, benefit-cost, socioeconomic impacts, risk and uncertainty, and financial analyses. This chapter of the EIR/EIS reports the estimated socioeconomic impactsThe other economic analyses outlined in the DWR guidebook were not conducted as part of the NEPA/CEQA compliance documentation. EIR/S Response To Comments The issue related to the cost estimate or financial viability as raised by the commenter addresses the merits of the project and does not raise any issues with the environmental analysis provided in the EIR/S. Project Description Inconsistency SDWA-322 Project Includes:

Facilities Environmental Commitments Operating Criteria In particular, the project includes new operating restrictions on existing south Delta pumps. Petition Operating Criteria Lacks Credibility Not Supported By Financial Feasibility Analysis Funding agency analysis assumes WaterFix does not require new restrictions on the existing south Delta pumps. SDWA-322 EIR/EIS Is Clear That Operating Criteria For South Delta Only Apply To WaterFix "these proposed operational criteria would only take effect

after the proposed conveyance facilities are operational (Final EIR/EIS, page 3-263) These newly proposed OMR criteria (and associated head of Old River gate operations) are in response to expected changes under the PA, and only applicable after the proposed north Delta diversion becomes operational. Until the north Delta diversion becomes operational, only the OMR criteria under the current BiOps apply to CVP/SWP operations. Biological Opinion Includes Similar Statements SDWA-322 MWD and DWR Economic Analysis Assume Identical South Delta Operating Criteria

MWD White Paper says operating criteria just an assumption for the EIR. Actual operations will be determined by adaptive management, so use same operating criteria with and without the project. Compare WaterFix to Existing Conveyance With WaterFix Operating Criteria MWD staff to Board (March 27, 2018 meeting) no one knows whether regulations will become tighter in the future, but if they do, these things kind of move togetherso thats the 1.3 million acre feet of incremental water supply improvement that weve talked about for a long time here and we still think thats a pretty good estimate of the difference between with and without the project. Change to Project Description Increases Water Yield from 0.2maf to 1.3maf

SDWA-322 MWD Staff Says Their Project Description Applies To Future Water Allocation SDWA-322 MWD says 12% change to cost share increases SWP water supply by 156,000 acre feet. SDWA-322 Master Agreement For Unsubscribed Capacity (33%): Major Change to Project Description

Increases MWD to at least 65% share. MWD staff on 33% capacity: thats ours to manage and make decisions on. MWD Staff Comments on expected Master Agreement. SDWA-322 Agreement Still Being Developed. Hope that CVP will lease back the 33%

capacity (seems very unlikely). Water supply benefits of 33% capacity are calculated using their project description. Negative impact on exchange contractor and wildlife refuge water supply in some years. Estimate an additional 150,000 af of avg. water supply for SWP if CVP does not SDWA-322 New WaterFix Financial Plan Has Major Impacts on Water Supply Allocation and Public Interest Annual Acre Feet of Delta Exports. (table derived from MWD staff presentation and board materials) No Action Alternative CWF (67% SWP/33% CVP)

CVP leases 33% capacity. CVP SWP Total 2,115,000 2,585,000 4,700,000 2,094,000 2,906,000 5,000,000 1,665,000

3,056,000 4,721,000 CWF (67% SWP/33% MWD) No CVP lease of 33%. Most likely case Under unsubscribed capacity Master Agreement, WaterFix shifts about 450,000 af of water from agricultural to urban users. SDWA-322 Summary and Conclusions Lack of financial feasibility and economic benefit-cost analysis reduces credibility of Ms. Buchholz testimony.

No support for economic public interest claims. Negative water supply and economic effects on agriculture are likely. Project description is not credible. Major current changes required by financial necessity. Will more changes be required in the future? Dr. Shires testimony is mostly irrelevant. Board Could Take Actions To Ensure SDWA-322 Consistent Analyses and Protect Public Interest

Petitioners should provide Master Agreement. (and supplemental EIR/EIS) Financial feasibility analysis of proposed project to safeguard against additional financially driven project changes. Require full public interest analysis, especially environmental, of using a no-project baseline consistent with Petitioners economic analysis and financial planning, the Existing Conveyance With WaterFix Operating Criteria.

Recently Viewed Presentations

  • Name of presentation - Helena High School

    Name of presentation - Helena High School

    Early forms of proto-capitalism and free markets were present in the early form. Merchant capitalism was developed between the 8th-12th centuries, which some refer to as ... Islamic luster-painted ceramics were imitated by Italian potters during the Renaissance. Calligraphy, an...
  • HARIS 5O I would choose a hatchet for

    HARIS 5O I would choose a hatchet for

    With the hatchet, I could survive in the woods. Brian survived in the woods with only a hatchet at first. He used the hatchet to make weapons. He also used it for safety and protection. A hatchet is more important...
  • MEASUREMENTS OF MAX-IV GIRDER SYSTEMS Christopher W. Ostenfeld

    MEASUREMENTS OF MAX-IV GIRDER SYSTEMS Christopher W. Ostenfeld

    Radial vs tangential coil. Other. Support material. Choice of bearings. IMMW 18, New York. Harmonic coil measurements. Several things to consider. Single long coil vs . short segmented coils. Compensated vs . non-compensated. Integration. vs voltage measurements. Radial vs .
  • danube-inco.net

    danube-inco.net

    WBC-INCO.NET WP3 - Report on opportunities to access S&T Infrastructures Davor Kozmus, MHEST Steering Platform Meeting 29. October 2009, Zagreb T3.4: Analysis of opportunities t
  • More About Matter - portnet.org

    More About Matter - portnet.org

    More About Matter Physical and Chemical Properties * * Density can change under different pressure and temperature conditions. This is especially true for gases which can expand and contract in volume easily. * Density Because all matter has mass and...
  • An LDPC Decoder With Time-Domain Analog and Digital Mixed ...

    An LDPC Decoder With Time-Domain Analog and Digital Mixed ...

    The resultant parity-check matrix is very sparse. Look at this figure, the white blocks are all zero sub-matrices. We can find that the number of zero sub-matrices is larger than the upper matrix. This means that the complexity of the...
  • Derivatives of e^x and ln⁡x - Mr. Voci's Website

    Derivatives of e^x and ln⁡x - Mr. Voci's Website

    Derivative of ?? ??? ??=??????. In other words, keep the exponent the same and multiply by the derivative of the exponent. This is a process called differentiation by substitution. (though it may not be necessary for all problems) Remember: ?...
  • Maps - Airbus

    Maps - Airbus

    Maps. DD MONTH YEAR. Presentation title runs here (go to Header and Footer to edit this text) *The source for the world mapis UN.