Advanced Lake Leaders Conference - UWSP

Advanced Lake Leaders Conference - UWSP

Advanced Lake Leaders Conference Thomas A. Heberlein Sometimes it is OK to judge book by its cover Attitudes are like rocks in a river Many are underwater and you cannot see them perhaps the most dangerous You dont go down the river trying to move them out of the way (dynamite!)

But you must know their location and how to read the water to successfully navigate. Attitudes and solving environmental problems: The Three Fixes The environment doesnt have problems, we as humans have problems When we have problems with the environment, there are three ways of trying to fix them Technological Fix Cognitive Fix

Structural Fix Problem of Flooding in the US Huge Flood Loses 1920s-30s The response was the change nature By using technology (Hence the Technological Fix) Massive Dam Building Program Billions of Dollars Spent Assessment of Flood Losses 30 years later Rivers were modified BUT... Flood Losses INCREASED!

Why? Dams changed the behavior of the river and the attitudes and behavior of people as well Rivers were sort of controlled Fewer Floods People thought they were safe Moved into Flood Plain The Technological Fix, seems to avoid people but it doesnt.

The Cognitive Fix Lets Change Human Behavior Get the people rather than the rivers out of the flood plain Chicago Geographers: Educate the Public (aka Knowledge Deficiency Model) Created Flood Plain Maps Tried them out in Kansas City They didnt work

The Structural Fix Who really owns houses? Asked the Chicago geographers. Bankers Smaller Group Easy to Target More Rational No Loans in the Flood Plain Flood Insurance

Flood Plain Zoning The Three Fixes in Stockholm How do you reduce traffic in the Center of the City Solving Auto Crowding in Stockholm Technological Fix Tear down buildings, build new roads and bridges (change the environment) Cognitive Fix Massive advertising campaign trying to

convince people to not drive down town Structural Fix Trngselskatt Crowding Tax was implemented And tested in an adaptive management framework Reduced travel in the center of the city over 20 % Passed the inter-ocular

traumatic test Continues today to reduce crowding in the center How the Three Fixes Works Technological Cognitive Structural

What Changes Environment Human Behavior Human Behavior How Change is Achieved Technological change influences the

environment directly Information changes human behavior Organizational and/or technological change influences human behavior What Happens Environmental

variation is modified Attitudes change and behavior change follows Behaviors are changed. Attitude change may follow Role of Attitudes Developments must

be consistent with dominant public attitudes and values Effective change in attitude is necessary and attitudes must influence behavior Structural changes must be consistent with dominant public attitudes and values

Target Must change only key groups or key individuals Must change general public as individuals Must change key decision makers and other gate keepers

Benefit Usually effective at modifying the environment in predictable ways Consistent with freedom and responsibility values. Particularly important in the USA

Likely to be effective with lower cost and with fewer negative effects than the Technological Fix High High Low

Public Acceptability Problems High cost. Can fail to solve problem and can create other problems It is difficult to change Low public public attitudes, and acceptability in the

often these attitudes US. Seen as social have little to do with engineering. Design what people actually problems because of do political compromises Other Examples of Fixes The Department Coffee Room The Merrimac River Crossing Lead Free Gasoline Heberleins 1974 Porsche

The Departmental Coffee Room Problem--Using Styrofoam Cups How to change behavior and save the environment? Cognitive Fix Put up a sign Structural Fix Provide only paper/ or China cups Technological Fix Coffee fountains Lesson: Environmental Fixes must be consistent with attitudes and culture The Merrimac River Crossing

Problem--River Crossing Solutions: Ferry, Bridge or None Ferry doesnt allow crossing in the winter Other Technological Fixes Use railroad bridge in the winter Ice Road Lesson: Technological Fixes must be consistent with attitudes and culture Lead Free Gasoline Problem: Reduce lead in the environment by providing Lead Free Gasoline--How do you get people to use it

Cognitive Fix--Educate the Public Structural Fix Converters Required Smaller nozzle required Passed Law Requiring Technological Fix?? Build lead processor into cars--shell shot out put! Heberleins 1974 Porsche Problem: How to get people to wear seat belts? Cognitive Fix: Educate the Public Structural Fix: Interlock Device Car wont start unless seat belts locked

Technological Fix? Automatic Seat Belts Air Bags Lesson: Structural Fixes must be consistent with attitudes and culture Attitudes and the Three Fixes Technological Developments must be consistent with broad Public Attitudes Cognitive

Effective Attitude Change is Central and Behaviors Must Follow Attitudes Structural Structural Changes must be consistent with broad Public Attitudes Conclusion No matter which Fix you try you must have scientific information on attitudes or ...

Reducing Algae in Lake Mendota The Technological FixChange Nature Food Web Management Project Goal was to reduce algae by increasing the number of planktivores By decreasing the number of little fish that ate planktivores How? By dumping in a lot of big fish (walleyes and

northerns) to eat the little fish ONE PROBLEM They Forgot the Top Predator! At the ecosystem scale for lakes, this role of humans is insufficiently appreciated and poorly anticipated. This predator learns rapidly. It communicates quickly. A modest number of those most experienced and skilled can quickly undo a carefully planned food web manipulation. James F. Kitchell and Stephen R. Carpenter,

Angler numbers increased by almost 600% Ice Fishermen Came to the limnology lab To ask to use the phone In the days before cell phones To order pizzas And the scientists helped them out, which I guess is only reasonable in a food chain experiment We need as much knowledge

of the humans outside the lake as we do of biology of the lake of the 33 authors of the summary book, not one was a social science IT WASNT THE LIMNOLOGISTSS FAULT At all of UW and the WDNR there was nowhere near the capacity to understand angler population dynamics Or farmer behavior (the current problem for the water quality) Sociologists (namely me) dont do any better The sad story of cleaning up Delavan Lake

1986 Heberlein Directs WRM Masters 16 Students Designed Lake Delavan Management Plan Technological FixChanged Nature The WRM curriculum integrates the biological and physical sciences (which identify and measure problems) with engineering (which provides technological alternatives) and law and the social sciences (which assess needs and potential for institutional response). By 1989, a comprehensive rehabilitation project began.

The $7 million project was completed within three years and included: Drawing down the lake's water level by 10 feet to facilitate the eradication of the entire fish population. Building three ponds before the water entered the inlet and dredging a sediment control channel in the inlet. Reconstructing the dam at the end of the outlet. Treating the bottom of the lake to trap phosphorus sediments and prevent them from re-entering the lake. Constructing a peninsula near Community Park to divert sediment-laden water by redirecting it toward the outlet. Restocking game fish as the lake refilled to its normal level.

Does this sound like social science to you?? The project was a success! 1991 water clarity was at 26 feet deep. Property values went up Some sold theirs and walked with the profits People could swim and fish Our CV surveys showed owners would pay $80100 annually for this improvement But this money was never collected

Anglers from around the state were attracted by the fisheries They didnt pay any clean water fees either 2005lake is dirty again AND NO MONEY TO CLEAN UP! We FORGOT social sustainability We failed to build in institutional mechanisms to promote sustainability Use Enough WHY? Not enough social sciences 1 social psychologist (me)

1 economist (visiting faculty) Social Science! Of the 16 students only 3 had any real social science training Failure at the Grand Canyon The Direct Experience Principle One of four principles helpful for understanding attitudes

The Consistency Principle The Identify Principle The Specificity Principle Attitudes based on direct experience are stronger, less likely to change, and more likely to influence our actions. Many attitudes are not based on direct experience Attitudes of Visitors (oar/motor) Satisfaction of visitors who take oar and motor powered trips is high and about the same. BUT . . . visitors take only one trip.

Few have Direct Experience with BOTH kinds of trips. So without this, how do they know? Anyone who has been on both types of trips knows there are vast differences. Best of Both Experiment Worked with an outfitter who ran both motorized and oar powered trips floated half of the canyon on oar or motor powered trips then switched to the opposite kind.

Attitudes measured after both experiences Experimental Design giving Direct Experience Shelby, B. Contrasting Recreational Experiences: Motors and Oars in the Grand Canyon. Journal of Soil and Water Conservation 35 (1980): 12931. After taking BOTH trips Choose oars for next trip 87%

Recommend oars to friend 79% Oars better 90% Oars described as quiet, relaxing, natural, friendly Motors described as loud, big, noisy, crowded Data pass the inter ocular traumatic test So with such compelling data why are motors still on the river?

Blame Managers? Solution National Park Service Managers on another Best Both Trip Bill WhalenDirector National Park Service Howard ChapmanWestern Region Director Merle StittSuperintendent of Grand Canyon National Park Staff of the Secretary of Interiors office

Based on their experience they strongly supported phasing out motors as part of the Inner Canyon Management Plan Blame Politics? A first term senator Orrin Hatch from the State of Utah added an amendment to the NPS appropriations bill If the river management plan with the motorized rafting phase-out was implemented funding for river management at GRCA would be stripped from the budget.

AND MOTORS STAYED ON THE RIVER. Blame Science??? And the scientist? Were the right studies done? Enough social science? and in the right place? All the science I recommended was done in the canyon Attitude surveys of visitors, careful measurement of contacts on the river at

varying density levels No studies done of the rafting industry the community impacts of a ban on oars demonstration projects to understand how transition from motors to oars Think Beyond the Rim William Freudenburg Forty years ago, when a new trend called environmentalism

swept the county and much of the planet, respected professors were pretty sure they knew what needed to be done. In a nutshell, their ideas involved careful research on every single species on the planet except onethe one that was actually at the root of almost everything they called an environmental problem. For that one species, they said that, instead, what we needed to do was educate

Use Enough Social Science Our current efforts are like shooting an elephant with a 22 One Survey is Not Enough! We need teams of social scientists to join the natural scientiststo balance biocentrism Sociologists (understanding communities) Political Scientists (governance) Social Psychologists (attitudes) Economists (consumer surplus, expenditures) Even Anthropologists

Recently Viewed Presentations

  • The Rectangular Channel Steven A. Jones BIEN 501

    The Rectangular Channel Steven A. Jones BIEN 501

    The Rectangular Channel Steven A. Jones BIEN 501 Friday, April 4th, 2008 The Rectangular Channel Major Learning Objectives: Deduce boundary conditions for a 2-dimensional laminar internal flow problem.
  • Evolución y Sistemas Evolutivos - fgalindosoria

    Evolución y Sistemas Evolutivos - fgalindosoria

    a partir del modelo de neurona desarrollado por Mc Cullot y Pitts generamos nuestra propia propuesta, basada en una representación matricial de la red neuronal, en la cual cada una de las señales de entrada a las neuronas se representa...
  • Mad Hatters: Saving the World Or: Potential applications

    Mad Hatters: Saving the World Or: Potential applications

    Regardless of pollution prevention approaches, reductions in mercury emissions and concentrations in the food chain will take years to achieve. But exposure can be reduced now by encouraging people to change consumption patterns of fish, the primary source of mercury...

    This is a powerpoint to teach number sense tricks. Credit goes to Jeff Boyd for its creation and placement in the public domain.Edited by [email protected] on Nov. 3, 2017
  • Lecture Outlines Natural Disasters, 5th edition

    Lecture Outlines Natural Disasters, 5th edition

    Lecture Outlines Natural Disasters, 7th edition Patrick L. Abbott ... Flood Frequency Larger floods longer recurrence times between each Analyze by plotting flood-discharge volumes vs. recurrence interval, construct flood-frequency curve Flood-frequency curves different for different streams Can ...
  • Motivation towards Team-work

    Motivation towards Team-work

    4. Maintaining the Team Effort (cont.) As a member of the team, do you assume a variety of roles? Task Roles Initiating activity, seeking information, seeking opinion, giving information, giving opinion, elaborating, coordinating, and summarizing. Team Building Roles Encouraging, standard...
  • The DSM-5: How we cured 'dementia', but Depression is Here to ...

    The DSM-5: How we cured 'dementia', but Depression is Here to ...

    CATIE-ADLon S. Schneider et. Al. Primary outcome - time to discontinuation for any reason. great "real world" approach to study design. Atypicals were no better "tolerated" Big media spin after data released: Known higher mortality per FDA. Now evidence of...
  • 50 tips for Management Reporter - Boyer & Associates

    50 tips for Management Reporter - Boyer & Associates

    Management Reporter (MR) What is it? Management Reporter is a real-time financial reporting application designed to empower information workers to quickly and easily create, generate, secure, and publish financial statements, such as Profit and Loss (P&L) statements, balance sheets, and...